{-# OPTIONS_GHC -Wunused-imports #-} {-# LANGUAGE NondecreasingIndentation #-} {-| Compile-time irrelevance. In type theory with compile-time irrelevance à la Pfenning (LiCS 2001), variables in the context are annotated with relevance attributes. @@ Γ = r₁x₁:A₁, ..., rⱼxⱼ:Aⱼ @@ To handle irrelevant projections, we also record the current relevance attribute in the judgement. For instance, this attribute is equal to to 'Irrelevant' if we are in an irrelevant position, like an irrelevant argument. @@ Γ ⊢r t : A @@ Only relevant variables can be used: @@ (Relevant x : A) ∈ Γ -------------------- Γ ⊢r x : A @@ Irrelevant global declarations can only be used if @r = Irrelevant@. When we enter a @r'@-relevant function argument, we compose the @r@ with @r'@ and (left-)divide the attributes in the context by @r'@. @@ Γ ⊢r t : (r' x : A) → B r' \ Γ ⊢(r'·r) u : A --------------------------------------------------------- Γ ⊢r t u : B[u/x] @@ No surprises for abstraction: @@ Γ, (r' x : A) ⊢r : B ----------------------------- Γ ⊢r λxt : (r' x : A) → B @@ This is different for runtime irrelevance (erasure) which is ``flat'', meaning that once one is in an irrelevant context, all new assumptions will be usable, since they are turned relevant once entering the context. See Conor McBride (WadlerFest 2016), for a type system in this spirit: We use such a rule for runtime-irrelevance: @@ Γ, (q \ q') x : A ⊢q t : B ------------------------------ Γ ⊢q λxt : (q' x : A) → B @@ Conor's system is however set up differently, with a very different variable rule: @@ (q x : A) ∈ Γ -------------- Γ ⊢q x : A Γ, (q·p) x : A ⊢q t : B ----------------------------- Γ ⊢q λxt : (p x : A) → B Γ ⊢q t : (p x : A) → B Γ' ⊢qp u : A ------------------------------------------------- Γ + Γ' ⊢q t u : B[u/x] @@ -} module Agda.TypeChecking.Irrelevance where import Control.Monad.Except import Agda.Interaction.Options import Agda.Syntax.Common import Agda.Syntax.Internal import Agda.Syntax.Concrete.Pretty import Agda.TypeChecking.Monad import Agda.TypeChecking.Pretty import Agda.TypeChecking.Reduce import Agda.TypeChecking.Substitute.Class import Agda.Utils.Lens import Agda.Utils.Maybe import Agda.Utils.Monad -- | Check whether something can be used in a position of the given relevance. -- -- This is a substitute for double-checking that only makes sure -- relevances are correct. See issue #2640. -- -- Used in unifier (@ unifyStep Solution{}@). -- -- At the moment, this implements McBride-style irrelevance, -- where Pfenning-style would be the most accurate thing. -- However, these two notions only differ how they handle -- bound variables in a term. Here, we are only concerned -- in the free variables, used meta-variables, and used -- (irrelevant) definitions. -- class UsableRelevance a where usableRel :: (ReadTCState m, HasConstInfo m, MonadTCEnv m, MonadAddContext m, MonadDebug m) => Relevance -> a -> m Bool instance UsableRelevance Term where usableRel rel = \case Var i vs -> do irel <- getRelevance <$> domOfBV i let ok = irel `moreRelevant` rel reportSDoc "tc.irr" 50 $ "Variable" <+> prettyTCM (var i) <+> text ("has relevance " ++ show irel ++ ", which is " ++ (if ok then "" else "NOT ") ++ "more relevant than " ++ show rel) return ok `and2M` usableRel rel vs Def f vs -> do frel <- relOfConst f return (frel `moreRelevant` rel) `and2M` usableRel rel vs Con c _ vs -> usableRel rel vs Lit l -> return True Lam _ v -> usableRel rel v Pi a b -> usableRel rel (a,b) Sort s -> usableRel rel s Level l -> return True MetaV m vs -> do mrel <- getRelevance <$> lookupMetaModality m return (mrel `moreRelevant` rel) `and2M` usableRel rel vs DontCare v -> usableRel rel v -- TODO: allow irrelevant things to be used in DontCare position? Dummy{} -> return True instance UsableRelevance a => UsableRelevance (Type' a) where usableRel rel (El _ t) = usableRel rel t instance UsableRelevance Sort where usableRel rel = \case Univ _ l -> usableRel rel l Inf _ _ -> return True SizeUniv -> return True LockUniv -> return True LevelUniv -> return True IntervalUniv -> return True PiSort a s1 s2 -> usableRel rel (a,s1,s2) FunSort s1 s2 -> usableRel rel (s1,s2) UnivSort s -> usableRel rel s MetaS x es -> usableRel rel es DefS d es -> usableRel rel $ Def d es DummyS{} -> return True instance UsableRelevance Level where usableRel rel (Max _ ls) = usableRel rel ls instance UsableRelevance PlusLevel where usableRel rel (Plus _ l) = usableRel rel l instance UsableRelevance a => UsableRelevance [a] where usableRel rel = andM . map (usableRel rel) instance (UsableRelevance a, UsableRelevance b) => UsableRelevance (a,b) where usableRel rel (a,b) = usableRel rel a `and2M` usableRel rel b instance (UsableRelevance a, UsableRelevance b, UsableRelevance c) => UsableRelevance (a,b,c) where usableRel rel (a,b,c) = usableRel rel a `and2M` usableRel rel b `and2M` usableRel rel c instance UsableRelevance a => UsableRelevance (Elim' a) where usableRel rel (Apply a) = usableRel rel a usableRel rel (Proj _ p) = do prel <- relOfConst p return $ prel `moreRelevant` rel usableRel rel (IApply x y v) = usableRel rel v instance UsableRelevance a => UsableRelevance (Arg a) where usableRel rel (Arg info u) = let rel' = getRelevance info in usableRel (rel `composeRelevance` rel') u instance UsableRelevance a => UsableRelevance (Dom a) where usableRel rel Dom{unDom = u} = usableRel rel u instance (Subst a, UsableRelevance a) => UsableRelevance (Abs a) where usableRel rel abs = underAbstraction_ abs $ \u -> usableRel rel u -- | Check whether something can be used in a position of the given modality. -- -- This is a substitute for double-checking that only makes sure -- modalities are correct. See issue #2640. -- -- Used in unifier (@ unifyStep Solution{}@). -- -- This uses McBride-style modality checking. -- It does not differ from Pfenning-style if we -- are only interested in the modality of the -- free variables, used meta-variables, and used -- definitions. -- class UsableModality a where usableMod :: (ReadTCState m, HasConstInfo m, MonadTCEnv m, MonadAddContext m, MonadDebug m, MonadReduce m, MonadError Blocker m) => Modality -> a -> m Bool instance UsableModality Term where usableMod mod u = do case u of Var i vs -> do imod <- getModality <$> domOfBV i let ok = imod `moreUsableModality` mod reportSDoc "tc.irr" 50 $ "Variable" <+> prettyTCM (var i) <+> text ("has modality " ++ show imod ++ ", which is a " ++ (if ok then "" else "NOT ") ++ "more usable modality than " ++ show mod) return ok `and2M` usableMod mod vs Def f vs -> do fmod <- modalityOfConst f -- Pure modalities don't matter here, only positional ones, hence remove -- them from the equation. let ok = setCohesion Flat fmod `moreUsableModality` mod reportSDoc "tc.irr" 50 $ "Definition" <+> prettyTCM (Def f []) <+> text ("has modality " ++ show fmod ++ ", which is a " ++ (if ok then "" else "NOT ") ++ "more usable modality than " ++ show mod) return ok `and2M` usableMod mod vs Con c o vs -> do cmod <- modalityOfConst (conName c) let ok = cmod `moreUsableModality` mod reportSDoc "tc.irr" 50 $ "The constructor" <+> prettyTCM (Con c o []) <+> text ("has the modality " ++ show cmod ++ ", which is " ++ (if ok then "" else "NOT ") ++ "more usable than the modality " ++ show mod ++ ".") return ok `and2M` usableMod mod vs Lit l -> return True Lam info v -> usableModAbs info mod v -- Even if Pi contains Type, here we check it as a constructor for terms in the universe. Pi a b -> usableMod domMod (unEl $ unDom a) `and2M` usableModAbs (getArgInfo a) mod (unEl <$> b) where domMod = mapQuantity (composeQuantity $ getQuantity a) $ mapCohesion (composeCohesion $ getCohesion a) mod -- Andrea 15/10/2020 not updating these cases yet, but they are quite suspicious, -- do we have special typing rules for Sort and Level? Sort s -> usableMod mod s Level l -> return True MetaV m vs -> do mmod <- lookupMetaModality m let ok = mmod `moreUsableModality` mod reportSDoc "tc.irr" 50 $ "Metavariable" <+> prettyTCM (MetaV m []) <+> text ("has modality " ++ show mmod ++ ", which is a " ++ (if ok then "" else "NOT ") ++ "more usable modality than " ++ show mod) (return ok `and2M` usableMod mod vs) `or2M` do u <- instantiate u caseMaybe (isMeta u) (usableMod mod u) $ \ m -> throwError (UnblockOnMeta m) DontCare v -> usableMod mod v Dummy{} -> return True usableModAbs :: (Subst a, MonadAddContext m, UsableModality a, ReadTCState m, HasConstInfo m, MonadReduce m, MonadError Blocker m) => ArgInfo -> Modality -> Abs a -> m Bool usableModAbs info mod abs = underAbstraction (setArgInfo info $ __DUMMY_DOM__) abs $ \ u -> usableMod mod u instance UsableRelevance a => UsableModality (Type' a) where usableMod mod (El _ t) = usableRel (getRelevance mod) t instance UsableModality Sort where usableMod mod s = usableRel (getRelevance mod) s instance UsableModality Level where usableMod mod (Max _ ls) = usableRel (getRelevance mod) ls -- instance UsableModality PlusLevel where -- usableMod mod ClosedLevel{} = return True -- usableMod mod (Plus _ l) = usableMod mod l instance UsableModality a => UsableModality [a] where usableMod mod = andM . map (usableMod mod) instance (UsableModality a, UsableModality b) => UsableModality (a,b) where usableMod mod (a,b) = usableMod mod a `and2M` usableMod mod b instance UsableModality a => UsableModality (Elim' a) where usableMod mod (Apply a) = usableMod mod a usableMod mod (Proj _ p) = do pmod <- modalityOfConst p return $ pmod `moreUsableModality` mod usableMod mod (IApply x y v) = usableMod mod v instance UsableModality a => UsableModality (Arg a) where usableMod mod (Arg info u) = let mod' = getModality info in usableMod (mod `composeModality` mod') u instance UsableModality a => UsableModality (Dom a) where usableMod mod Dom{unDom = u} = usableMod mod u usableAtModality' :: MonadConstraint TCM -- Note: This weird-looking constraint is to trick GHC into accepting -- that an instance of MonadConstraint TCM will exist, even if we -- can't import the module in which it is defined. => Maybe Sort -> WhyCheckModality -> Modality -> Term -> TCM () usableAtModality' ms why mod t = catchConstraint (UsableAtModality why ms mod t) $ do whenM (maybe (pure True) isFibrant ms) $ do res <- runExceptT $ usableMod mod t case res of Right b -> unless b $ typeError . GenericDocError =<< formatWhy Left blocker -> patternViolation blocker where formatWhy = do compatible <- optCubicalCompatible <$> pragmaOptions cubical <- isJust . optCubical <$> pragmaOptions let context | cubical = "in Cubical Agda," | compatible = "to maintain compatibility with Cubical Agda," | otherwise = "when --without-K is enabled," explanation what | cubical || compatible = [ "" , fsep ( "Note:":pwords context ++ pwords what ++ pwords "must be usable at the modality" ++ pwords "in which the function was defined, since it will be" ++ pwords "used for computing transports" ) , "" ] | otherwise = [] case why of IndexedClause -> vcat $ ( fsep ( pwords "This clause has target type" ++ [prettyTCM t] ++ pwords "which is not usable at the required modality" ++ [pure (attributesForModality mod) <> "."] ) : explanation "the target type") -- Arguments sometimes need to be transported too: IndexedClauseArg forced the_arg -> vcat $ ( fsep (pwords "The argument" ++ [prettyTCM the_arg] ++ pwords "has type") : nest 2 (prettyTCM t) : fsep ( pwords "which is not usable at the required modality" ++ [pure (attributesForModality mod) <> "."] ) : explanation "this argument's type") -- Note: if a generated clause is modality-incorrect, that's a -- bug in the LHS modality check GeneratedClause -> __IMPOSSIBLE_VERBOSE__ . show =<< prettyTCM t <+> "is not usable at the required modality" <+> pure (attributesForModality mod) _ -> prettyTCM t <+> "is not usable at the required modality" <+> pure (attributesForModality mod) usableAtModality :: MonadConstraint TCM => WhyCheckModality -> Modality -> Term -> TCM () usableAtModality = usableAtModality' Nothing -- * Propositions -- | Is a type a proposition? (Needs reduction.) isPropM :: (LensSort a, PrettyTCM a, PureTCM m, MonadBlock m) => a -> m Bool isPropM a = do traceSDoc "tc.prop" 80 ("Is " <+> prettyTCM a <+> "of sort" <+> prettyTCM (getSort a) <+> "in Prop?") $ do abortIfBlocked (getSort a) <&> \case Prop{} -> True _ -> False {-# SPECIALIZE isIrrelevantOrPropM :: Dom Type -> TCM Bool #-} isIrrelevantOrPropM :: (LensRelevance a, LensSort a, PrettyTCM a, PureTCM m, MonadBlock m) => a -> m Bool isIrrelevantOrPropM x = return (isIrrelevant x) `or2M` isPropM x -- * Fibrant types -- | Is a type fibrant (i.e. Type, Prop)? isFibrant :: (LensSort a, PureTCM m, MonadBlock m) => a -> m Bool isFibrant a = abortIfBlocked (getSort a) <&> \case Univ u _ -> univFibrancy u == IsFibrant Inf u _ -> univFibrancy u == IsFibrant SizeUniv{} -> False LockUniv{} -> False LevelUniv{} -> False IntervalUniv{} -> False PiSort{} -> False FunSort{} -> False UnivSort{} -> False MetaS{} -> False DefS{} -> False DummyS{} -> False -- | Cofibrant types are those that could be the domain of a fibrant -- pi type. (Notion by C. Sattler). isCoFibrantSort :: (LensSort a, PureTCM m, MonadBlock m) => a -> m Bool isCoFibrantSort a = abortIfBlocked (getSort a) <&> \case Univ u _ -> univFibrancy u == IsFibrant Inf u _ -> univFibrancy u == IsFibrant SizeUniv{} -> False LockUniv{} -> True LevelUniv{} -> False IntervalUniv{} -> True PiSort{} -> False FunSort{} -> False UnivSort{} -> False MetaS{} -> False DefS{} -> False DummyS{} -> False