rsync on windows has been broken by the upgrade to a newer version of cygwin. `rsync user@host:file file` opens the ssh connection, but hangs up with a protocol error. Apparently it doesn't get even the protocol version message from the server. Problem doesn't seem to affect the bundled ssh, just rsync. --[[Joey]] > Update: Apparently there are two ssh's! msysgit bundles one (did it used > to in PATH?) and git-annex bundles one from cygwin. msysgit's ends up > in Git/bin and git-annex's in Git/cmd. > > Seems that cygwin's rsync cannot use git's ssh for whatever reason. > > So the workaround is to > delete Git/bin/ssh.exe and leave Git/cmd/ssh.exe. Then rsync works. > However, this may screw up git's use of ssh or other stuff. > > Particularly, cygwin's ssh doesn't honor HOME anymore, instead using > the getpwent home, which doesn't exist. > > Also, see > [[webapp_fails_to_connect_to_ssh_repository___40__windows__41__]] > which is the inverse of this bug perhaps, or at least seems related. > > Using 2 ssh's that try to use config from different places seems like > a losing propisition. Need to find an rsync that works with git's ssh. > --[[Joey]] > > > Update: The git bin/ directory is only in PATH when inside "git bash". > > This bug only seems to affect using git-annex that way. The git bash > > PATH has `bin` before `cmd`. > > > > Also, git seems to work ok using the newer ssh from cygwin. > > However, that ssh tries to write to a .ssh/known_hosts > > in a cygwin location and so doesn't remember hosts. > > > > What a mess. You can install any version of Linux and get rsync, ssh, > > git that all integrate and work together. Or you can use Windows and > > enjoy the pain(TM) --[[Joey]] >>> Possible fixes: >>> >>> * Roll the bundled ssh and rsync back to the older versions. >>> >>> **This works**. And, seems that the older version of ssh from cygwin >>> looks at HOME, rather than getpwent home which the newer >>> cygwin ssh does. >>> >>> * Roll the bundled rsync back, drop ssh. Rely on msysgit's bundled ssh, >>> copying it into cmd so it's in PATH. Check: Does this combo work? >>> >>> **This works**! rsync 3.0.9 works ok with msysgit's bundled ssh. >>> rsync 3.1.1 is the one that needs a newer ssh. **[[done]]** >>> >>> Note that this means we're using an old version of rsync >>> from cygwin with libraries from a newer cygwin. That might prove >>> fragile as cygwin is upgraded. >>> >>> * Hope that msysgit gets updated to include a newer version of ssh >>> which works with the new rsync. >>> >>> (Seems reasonable as a long-term plan, assuming that the >>> new rsync's problem with ssh is that it needs a new one, and not some >>> special cygwin thing.) >>> >>> * Get rsync from somewhere else, perhaps msysgit. (Maybe also get ssh >>> from msysgit?) >>> * Keep the new rsync from cygwin, and build ssh from source, >>> patching it to use HOME in preference to getpwent home.