{-|
Module      : Idris.Elab.Clause
Description : Code to elaborate clauses.
Copyright   :
License     : BSD3
Maintainer  : The Idris Community.
-}
{-# LANGUAGE PatternGuards #-}
module Idris.Elab.Clause where

import Idris.AbsSyntax
import Idris.ASTUtils
import Idris.Core.CaseTree
import Idris.Core.Elaborate hiding (Tactic(..))
import Idris.Core.Evaluate
import Idris.Core.Execute
import Idris.Core.TT
import Idris.Core.Typecheck
import Idris.Core.WHNF
import Idris.Coverage
import Idris.DataOpts
import Idris.DeepSeq
import Idris.Delaborate
import Idris.Docstrings hiding (Unchecked)
import Idris.DSL
import Idris.Elab.AsPat
import Idris.Elab.Term
import Idris.Elab.Transform
import Idris.Elab.Type
import Idris.Elab.Utils
import Idris.Error
import Idris.Imports
import Idris.Inliner
import Idris.Output (iRenderResult, iWarn, iputStrLn, pshow, sendHighlighting)
import Idris.PartialEval
import Idris.Primitives
import Idris.Providers
import Idris.Termination
import Idris.Transforms
import IRTS.Lang

import Util.Pretty hiding ((<$>))
import Util.Pretty (pretty, text)

import Prelude hiding (id, (.))

import Control.Applicative hiding (Const)
import Control.Category
import Control.DeepSeq
import Control.Monad
import qualified Control.Monad.State.Lazy as LState
import Control.Monad.State.Strict as State
import Data.Char (isLetter, toLower)
import Data.List
import Data.List.Split (splitOn)
import qualified Data.Map as Map
import Data.Maybe
import qualified Data.Set as S
import qualified Data.Text as T
import Data.Word
import Debug.Trace
import Numeric

-- | Elaborate a collection of left-hand and right-hand pairs - that is, a
-- top-level definition.
elabClauses :: ElabInfo -> FC -> FnOpts -> Name -> [PClause] -> Idris ()
elabClauses info' fc opts n_in cs =
      do let n    = liftname info n_in
             info = info' { elabFC = Just fc }
         ctxt <- getContext
         ist  <- getIState
         optimise <- getOptimise
         let petrans = PETransform `elem` optimise
         inacc <- map fst <$> fgetState (opt_inaccessible . ist_optimisation n)

         -- Check n actually exists, with no definition yet
         let tys = lookupTy n ctxt
         let reflect = Reflection `elem` opts
         when (reflect && FCReflection `notElem` idris_language_extensions ist) $
           ierror $ At fc (Msg "You must turn on the FirstClassReflection extension to use %reflection")
         checkUndefined n ctxt
         unless (length tys > 1) $ do
           fty <- case tys of
              [] -> -- TODO: turn into a CAF if there's no arguments
                    -- question: CAFs in where blocks?
                    tclift $ tfail $ At fc (NoTypeDecl n)
              [ty] -> return ty
           let atys_in = map snd (getArgTys (normalise ctxt [] fty))
           let atys = map (\x -> (x, isCanonical x ctxt)) atys_in
           cs_elab <- mapM (elabClause info opts)
                           (zip [0..] cs)
           ctxt <- getContext
           -- pats_raw is the basic type checked version, no PE or forcing
           let optinfo = idris_optimisation ist
           let (pats_in, cs_full) = unzip cs_elab
           let pats_raw = map (simple_lhs ctxt) pats_in
           -- We'll apply forcing to the left hand side here, so that we don't
           -- do any unnecessary case splits
           let pats_forced = map (force_lhs optinfo) pats_raw

           logElab 3 $ "Elaborated patterns:\n" ++ show pats_raw
           logElab 5 $ "Forced patterns:\n" ++ show pats_forced

           solveDeferred fc n

           -- just ensure that the structure exists
           fmodifyState (ist_optimisation n) id
           addIBC (IBCOpt n)

           ist <- getIState
           ctxt <- getContext
           -- Don't apply rules if this is a partial evaluation definition,
           -- or we'll make something that just runs itself!
           let tpats = case specNames opts of
                            Nothing -> transformPats ist pats_in
                            _ -> pats_in

           -- If the definition is specialisable, this reduces the
           -- RHS
           pe_tm <- doPartialEval ist tpats

           let pats_pe = if petrans
                            then map (force_lhs optinfo . simple_lhs ctxt) pe_tm
                            else pats_forced

           let tcase = opt_typecase (idris_options ist)

           -- Look for 'static' names and generate new specialised
           -- definitions for them, as well as generating rewrite rules
           -- for partially evaluated definitions
           newrules <- if petrans
                          then mapM (\ e -> case e of
                                            Left _ -> return []
                                            Right (l, r) -> elabPE info fc n r) pats_pe
                          else return []

           -- Redo transforms with the newly generated transformations, so
           -- that the specialised application we've just made gets
           -- used in place of the general one
           ist <- getIState
           let pats_transformed = if petrans
                                     then transformPats ist pats_pe
                                     else pats_pe

           -- Summary of what's about to happen: Definitions go:
           --
           -- pats_in -> pats -> pdef -> pdef'

           -- addCaseDef builds case trees from <pdef> and <pdef'>

           -- pdef is the compile-time pattern definition, after forcing
           -- optimisation applied to LHS
           let pdef = map (\(ns, lhs, rhs) -> (map fst ns, lhs, rhs)) $
                          map debind pats_forced
           -- pdef_cov is the pattern definition without forcing, which
           -- we feed to the coverage checker (we need to know what the
           -- programmer wrote before forcing erasure)
           let pdef_cov
                    = map (\(ns, lhs, rhs) -> (map fst ns, lhs, rhs)) $
                          map debind pats_raw
           -- pdef_pe is the one which will get further optimised
           -- for run-time, with no forcing optimisation of the LHS because
           -- the affects erasure. Also, it's partially evaluated
           let pdef_pe = map debind pats_transformed

           logElab 5 $ "Initial typechecked patterns:\n" ++ show pats_raw
           logElab 5 $ "Initial typechecked pattern def:\n" ++ show pdef

           -- NOTE: Need to store original definition so that proofs which
           -- rely on its structure aren't affected by any changes to the
           -- inliner. Just use the inlined version to generate pdef' and to
           -- help with later inlinings.

           ist <- getIState
           let pdef_inl = inlineDef ist pdef

           numArgs <- tclift $ sameLength pdef

           case specNames opts of
                Just _ ->
                   do logElab 3 $ "Partially evaluated:\n" ++ show pats_pe
                _ -> return ()
           logElab 3 $ "Transformed:\n" ++ show pats_transformed

           erInfo <- getErasureInfo <$> getIState
           tree@(CaseDef scargs sc _) <- tclift $
                 simpleCase tcase (UnmatchedCase "Error") reflect CompileTime fc inacc atys pdef erInfo
           cov <- coverage
           pmissing <-
                   if cov && not (hasDefault pats_raw)
                      then do -- Generate clauses from the given possible cases
                              missing <- genClauses fc n
                                                 (map (\ (ns,tm,_) -> (ns, tm)) pdef)
                                                 cs_full
                              -- missing <- genMissing n scargs sc
                              missing' <- checkPossibles info fc True n missing
                              -- Filter out the ones which match one of the
                              -- given cases (including impossible ones)
                              let clhs = map getLHS pdef
                              logElab 2 $ "Must be unreachable (" ++ show (length missing') ++ "):\n" ++
                                          showSep "\n" (map showTmImpls missing') ++
                                         "\nAgainst: " ++
                                          showSep "\n" (map (\t -> showTmImpls (delab ist t)) (map getLHS pdef))
                              -- filter out anything in missing' which is
                              -- matched by any of clhs. This might happen since
                              -- unification may force a variable to take a
                              -- particular form, rather than force a case
                              -- to be impossible.
                              return missing' -- (filter (noMatch ist clhs) missing')
                      else return []
           let pcover = null pmissing

           -- pdef' is the version that gets compiled for run-time,
           -- so we start from the partially evaluated version
           pdef_in' <- applyOpts $ map (\(ns, lhs, rhs) -> (map fst ns, lhs, rhs)) pdef_pe
           ctxt <- getContext
           let pdef' = map (simple_rt ctxt) pdef_in'

           logElab 5 $ "After data structure transformations:\n" ++ show pdef'

           ist <- getIState
           let tot | pcover = Unchecked -- finish later
                   | AssertTotal `elem` opts = Total []
                   | PEGenerated `elem` opts = Generated
                   | otherwise = Partial NotCovering -- already know it's not total

           case tree of
               CaseDef _ _ [] -> return ()
               CaseDef _ _ xs -> mapM_ (\x ->
                   iputStrLn $ show fc ++
                                ":warning - Unreachable case: " ++
                                   show (delab ist x)) xs
           let knowncovering = (pcover && cov) || AssertTotal `elem` opts
           let defaultcase = if knowncovering
                                then STerm Erased
                                else UnmatchedCase $ "*** " ++
                                      show fc ++
                                       ":unmatched case in " ++ show n ++
                                       " ***"

           tree' <- tclift $ simpleCase tcase defaultcase reflect
                                        RunTime fc inacc atys pdef' erInfo
           logElab 3 $ "Unoptimised " ++ show n ++ ": " ++ show tree
           logElab 3 $ "Optimised: " ++ show tree'
           ctxt <- getContext
           ist <- getIState
           let opt = idris_optimisation ist
           putIState (ist { idris_patdefs = addDef n (force pdef_pe, force pmissing)
                                                (idris_patdefs ist) })
           let caseInfo = CaseInfo (inlinable opts) (inlinable opts) (dictionary opts)

           case lookupTyExact n ctxt of
               Just ty ->
                   do ctxt' <- do ctxt <- getContext
                                  tclift $
                                    addCasedef n erInfo caseInfo
                                                   tcase defaultcase
                                                   reflect
                                                   (AssertTotal `elem` opts)
                                                   atys
                                                   inacc
                                                   pats_forced
                                                   pdef
                                                   pdef' ty
                                                   ctxt
                      setContext ctxt'
                      addIBC (IBCDef n)
                      addDefinedName n
                      setTotality n tot
                      when (not reflect && PEGenerated `notElem` opts) $
                                           do totcheck (fc, n)
                                              defer_totcheck (fc, n)
                      when (tot /= Unchecked) $ addIBC (IBCTotal n tot)
                      i <- getIState
                      ctxt <- getContext
                      case lookupDef n ctxt of
                          (CaseOp _ _ _ _ _ cd : _) ->
                            let (scargs, sc) = cases_compiletime cd in
                              do let calls = map fst $ findCalls sc scargs
                                 -- let scg = buildSCG i sc scargs
                                 -- add SCG later, when checking totality
                                 logElab 2 $ "Called names: " ++ show calls
                                 -- if the definition is public, make sure
                                 -- it only uses public names
                                 nvis <- getFromHideList n
                                 case nvis of
                                      Just Public -> mapM_ (checkVisibility fc n Public Public) calls
                                      _ -> return ()
                                 addCalls n calls
                                 let rig = if linearArg (whnfArgs ctxt [] ty)
                                              then Rig1
                                              else RigW
                                 updateContext (setRigCount n (minRig ctxt rig calls))
                                 addIBC (IBCCG n)
                          _ -> return ()
                      return ()
  --                         addIBC (IBCTotal n tot)
               _ -> return ()
           -- Check it's covering, if 'covering' option is used. Chase
           -- all called functions, and fail if any of them are also
           -- 'Partial NotCovering'
           when (CoveringFn `elem` opts) $ checkAllCovering fc [] n n
           -- Add the 'AllGuarded' flag if it's guaranteed that every
           -- 'Inf' argument will be guarded by constructors in the result
           -- (allows productivity check to go under this function)
           checkIfGuarded n
           -- If this has %static arguments, cache the names of functions
           -- it calls for partial evaluation later
           ist <- getIState
           let statics = case lookupCtxtExact n (idris_statics ist) of
                              Just ns -> ns
                              Nothing -> []
           when (or statics) $ do getAllNames n
                                  return ()

  where
    noMatch i cs tm = all (\x -> case trim_matchClause i (delab' i x True True) tm of
                                      Right _ -> False
                                      Left miss -> True) cs
      where
        trim_matchClause i (PApp fcl fl ls) (PApp fcr fr rs)
            = let args = min (length ls) (length rs) in
                  matchClause i (PApp fcl fl (take args ls))
                                (PApp fcr fr (take args rs))

    checkUndefined n ctxt = case lookupDef n ctxt of
                                 [] -> return ()
                                 [TyDecl _ _] -> return ()
                                 _ -> tclift $ tfail (At fc (AlreadyDefined n))

    debind (Right (x, y)) = let (vs, x') = depat [] x
                                (_, y') = depat [] y in
                                (vs, x', y')
    debind (Left x)       = let (vs, x') = depat [] x in
                                (vs, x', Impossible)

    depat acc (Bind n (PVar rig t) sc) = depat ((n, t) : acc) (instantiate (P Bound n t) sc)
    depat acc x = (acc, x)


    getPVs (Bind x (PVar rig _) tm) = let (vs, tm') = getPVs tm
                                          in (x:vs, tm')
    getPVs tm = ([], tm)

    isPatVar vs (P Bound n _) = n `elem` vs
    isPatVar _ _ = False

    hasDefault cs | (Right (lhs, rhs) : _) <- reverse cs
                  , (pvs, tm) <- getPVs (explicitNames lhs)
                  , (f, args) <- unApply tm = all (isPatVar pvs) args
    hasDefault _ = False

    getLHS (_, l, _) = l

    -- Simplify the left hand side of a definition, to remove any lets
    -- that may have arisen during elaboration
    simple_lhs ctxt (Right (x, y))
        = Right (Idris.Core.Evaluate.simplify ctxt [] x, y)
    simple_lhs ctxt t = t

    force_lhs opts (Right (x, y)) = Right (forceWith opts x, y)
    force_lhs opts t = t

    simple_rt ctxt (p, x, y) = (p, x, force (uniqueBinders p
                                                (rt_simplify ctxt [] y)))

    specNames [] = Nothing
    specNames (Specialise ns : _) = Just ns
    specNames (_ : xs) = specNames xs

    sameLength ((_, x, _) : xs)
        = do l <- sameLength xs
             let (f, as) = unApply x
             if (null xs || l == length as) then return (length as)
                else tfail (At fc (Msg "Clauses have differing numbers of arguments "))
    sameLength [] = return 0

    -- Partially evaluate, if the definition is marked as specialisable
    doPartialEval ist pats =
           case specNames opts of
                Nothing -> return pats
                Just ns -> case partial_eval (tt_ctxt ist) ns pats of
                                Just t -> return t
                                Nothing -> ierror (At fc (Msg "No specialisation achieved"))

    minRig :: Context -> RigCount -> [Name] -> RigCount
    minRig c minr [] = minr
    minRig c minr (r : rs) = case lookupRigCountExact r c of
                                  Nothing -> minRig c minr rs
                                  Just rc -> minRig c (min minr rc) rs

forceWith :: Ctxt OptInfo -> Term -> Term
forceWith opts lhs = -- trace (show lhs ++ "\n==>\n" ++ show (force lhs) ++ "\n----") $
                      force lhs
  where
    -- If there's forced arguments, erase them
    force ap@(App _ _ _)
       | (fn@(P _ c _), args) <- unApply ap,
         Just copt <- lookupCtxtExact c opts
            = let args' = eraseArg 0 (forceable copt) args in
                  mkApp fn (map force args')
    force (App t f a)
       = App t (force f) (force a)
    -- We might have pat bindings, so go under them
    force (Bind n b sc) = Bind n b (force sc)
    -- Everything else, leave it alone
    force t = t

    eraseArg i fs (n : ns) | i `elem` fs = Erased : eraseArg (i + 1) fs ns
                           | otherwise = n : eraseArg (i + 1) fs ns
    eraseArg i _ [] = []


-- | Find 'static' applications in a term and partially evaluate them.
-- Return any new transformation rules
elabPE :: ElabInfo -> FC -> Name -> Term -> Idris [(Term, Term)]
-- Don't go deeper than 5 nested partially evaluated definitions in one go
-- (make this configurable? It's a good limit for most cases, certainly for
-- interfaces and polymorphic definitions, but maybe not for DSLs and
-- interpreters in complicated cases.
-- Possibly only worry about the limit if we've specialised the same function
-- a number of times in one go.)
elabPE info fc caller r | pe_depth info > 5 = return []
elabPE info fc caller r =
  do ist <- getIState
     let sa = filter (\ap -> fst ap /= caller) $ getSpecApps ist [] r
     rules <- mapM mkSpecialised sa
     return $ concat rules
  where
    -- Make a specialised version of the application, and
    -- add a PTerm level transformation rule, which is basically the
    -- new definition in reverse (before specialising it).
    -- RHS => LHS where implicit arguments are left blank in the
    -- transformation.

    -- Transformation rules are applied after every PClause elaboration

    mkSpecialised :: (Name, [(PEArgType, Term)]) -> Idris [(Term, Term)]
    mkSpecialised specapp_in = do
        ist <- getIState
        ctxt <- getContext
        (specTy, specapp) <- getSpecTy ist specapp_in
        let (n, newnm, specdecl) = getSpecClause ist specapp specTy
        let lhs = pe_app specdecl
        let rhs = pe_def specdecl
        let undef = case lookupDefExact newnm ctxt of
                         Nothing -> True
                         _ -> False
        logElab 5 $ show (newnm, undef, map (concreteArg ist) (snd specapp))
        idrisCatch
          (if (undef && all (concreteArg ist) (snd specapp)) then do
                cgns <- getAllNames n
                -- on the RHS of the new definition, we should reduce
                -- everything that's not itself static (because we'll
                -- want to be a PE version of those next)
                let cgns' = filter (\x -> x /= n &&
                                          notStatic ist x) cgns
                -- set small reduction limit on partial/productive things
                let maxred = case lookupTotal n ctxt of
                                  [Total _] -> 65536
                                  [Productive] -> 16
                                  _ -> 1
                let specnames = mapMaybe (specName (pe_simple specdecl))
                                         (snd specapp)
                descs <- mapM getStaticsFrom (map fst specnames)

                let opts = [Specialise ((if pe_simple specdecl
                                            then map (\x -> (x, Nothing)) cgns'
                                            else []) ++
                                         (n, Just maxred) : specnames ++
                                             concat descs)]
                logElab 3 $ "Specialising application: " ++ show specapp
                              ++ "\n in \n" ++ show caller ++
                              "\n with \n" ++ show opts
                              ++ "\nCalling: " ++ show cgns
                logElab 3 $ "New name: " ++ show newnm
                logElab 3 $ "PE definition type : " ++ (show specTy)
                            ++ "\n" ++ show opts
                logElab 2 $ "PE definition " ++ show newnm ++ ":\n" ++
                             showSep "\n"
                                (map (\ (lhs, rhs) ->
                                  (showTmImpls lhs ++ " = " ++
                                   showTmImpls rhs)) (pe_clauses specdecl))

                logElab 5 $ show n ++ " transformation rule: " ++
                           showTmImpls rhs ++ " ==> " ++ showTmImpls lhs

                elabType info defaultSyntax emptyDocstring [] fc opts newnm NoFC specTy
                let def = map (\(lhs, rhs) ->
                                 let lhs' = mapPT hiddenToPH $ stripUnmatchable ist lhs in
                                  PClause fc newnm lhs' [] rhs [])
                              (pe_clauses specdecl)
                trans <- elabTransform info fc False rhs lhs
                elabClauses (info {pe_depth = pe_depth info + 1}) fc
                            (PEGenerated:opts) newnm def
                return [trans]
             else return [])
          -- if it doesn't work, just don't specialise. Could happen for lots
          -- of valid reasons (e.g. local variables in scope which can't be
          -- lifted out).
          (\e -> do logElab 5 $ "Couldn't specialise: " ++ (pshow ist e)
                    return [])

    hiddenToPH (PHidden _) = Placeholder
    hiddenToPH x = x

    specName simpl (ImplicitS _, tm)
        | (P Ref n _, _) <- unApply tm = Just (n, Just (if simpl then 1 else 0))
    specName simpl (ExplicitS, tm)
        | (P Ref n _, _) <- unApply tm = Just (n, Just (if simpl then 1 else 0))
    specName simpl (ConstraintS, tm)
        | (P Ref n _, _) <- unApply tm = Just (n, Just (if simpl then 1 else 0))
    specName simpl _ = Nothing

    -- get the descendants of the name 'n' which are marked %static
    -- Marking a function %static essentially means it's used to construct
    -- programs, so should be evaluated by the partial evaluator
    getStaticsFrom :: Name -> Idris [(Name, Maybe Int)]
    getStaticsFrom n = do ns <- getAllNames n
                          i <- getIState
                          let statics = filter (staticFn i) ns
                          return (map (\n -> (n, Nothing)) statics)

    staticFn :: IState -> Name -> Bool
    staticFn i n =  case lookupCtxt n (idris_flags i) of
                            [opts] -> elem StaticFn opts
                            _ -> False

    notStatic ist n = case lookupCtxtExact n (idris_statics ist) of
                           Just s -> not (or s)
                           _ -> True

    concreteArg ist (ImplicitS _, tm) = concreteTm ist tm
    concreteArg ist (ExplicitS, tm) = concreteTm ist tm
    concreteArg ist _ = True

    concreteTm ist tm | (P _ n _, _) <- unApply tm =
        case lookupTy n (tt_ctxt ist) of
             [] -> False
             _ -> True
    concreteTm ist (Constant _) = True
    concreteTm ist (Bind n (Lam _ _) sc) = True
    concreteTm ist (Bind n (Pi _ _ _ _) sc) = True
    concreteTm ist (Bind n (Let _ _) sc) = concreteTm ist sc
    concreteTm ist _ = False

    -- get the type of a specialised application
    getSpecTy ist (n, args)
       = case lookupTy n (tt_ctxt ist) of
              [ty] -> let (specty_in, args') = specType args (explicitNames ty)
                          specty = normalise (tt_ctxt ist) [] (finalise specty_in)
                          t = mkPE_TyDecl ist args' (explicitNames specty) in
                          return (t, (n, args'))
--                             (normalise (tt_ctxt ist) [] (specType args ty))
              _ -> ifail $ "Ambiguous name " ++ show n ++ " (getSpecTy)"

    -- get the clause of a specialised application
    getSpecClause ist (n, args) specTy
       = let newnm = sUN ("PE_" ++ show (nsroot n) ++ "_" ++
                               qhash 5381 (showSep "_" (map showArg args))) in
                               -- UN (show n ++ show (map snd args)) in
             (n, newnm, mkPE_TermDecl ist newnm n specTy args)
      where showArg (ExplicitS, n) = qshow n
            showArg (ImplicitS _, n) = qshow n
            showArg _ = ""

            qshow (Bind _ _ _) = "fn"
            qshow (App _ f a) = qshow f ++ qshow a
            qshow (P _ n _) = show n
            qshow (Constant c) = show c
            qshow _ = ""

            -- Simple but effective string hashing...
            -- Keep it to 32 bits for readability/debuggability
            qhash :: Word64 -> String -> String
            qhash hash [] = showHex (abs hash `mod` 0xffffffff) ""
            qhash hash (x:xs) = qhash (hash * 33 + fromIntegral(fromEnum x)) xs

-- | Checks if the clause is a possible left hand side.
-- NOTE: A lot of this is repeated for reflected definitions in Idris.Elab.Term
-- One day, these should be merged, but until then remember that if you edit
-- this you might need to edit the other version...
checkPossible :: ElabInfo -> FC -> Bool -> Name -> PTerm -> Idris (Maybe PTerm)
checkPossible info fc tcgen fname lhs_in
   = do ctxt <- getContext
        i <- getIState
        let lhs = addImplPat i lhs_in
        logElab 10 $ "Trying missing case: " ++ showTmImpls lhs
        -- if the LHS type checks, it is possible
        case elaborate (constraintNS info) ctxt (idris_datatypes i) (idris_name i) (sMN 0 "patLHS") infP initEState
                            (erun fc (buildTC i info EImpossible [] fname
                                                (allNamesIn lhs_in)
                                                (infTerm lhs))) of
            OK (ElabResult lhs' _ _ ctxt' newDecls highlights newGName, _) ->
               do setContext ctxt'
                  processTacticDecls info newDecls
                  sendHighlighting highlights
                  updateIState $ \i -> i { idris_name = newGName }
                  let lhs_tm = normalise ctxt [] (orderPats (getInferTerm lhs'))
                  let emptyPat = hasEmptyPat ctxt (idris_datatypes i) lhs_tm
                  if emptyPat then
                     do logElab 10 $ "Empty type in pattern "
                        return Nothing
                    else
                      case recheck (constraintNS info) ctxt' [] (forget lhs_tm) lhs_tm of
                           OK (tm, _, _) ->
                                    do logElab 10 $ "Valid " ++ show tm ++ "\n"
                                                 ++ " from " ++ show lhs
                                       return (Just (delab' i tm True True))
                           err -> do logElab 10 $ "Conversion failure"
                                     return Nothing
            -- if it's a recoverable error, the case may become possible
            Error err -> do logLvl 10 $ "Impossible case " ++ (pshow i err)
                                 ++ "\n" ++ show (recoverableCoverage ctxt err,
                                                  validCoverageCase ctxt err)
                            -- tcgen means that it was generated by genClauses,
                            -- so only looking for an error. Otherwise, it
                            -- needs to be the right kind of error (a type mismatch
                            -- in the same family).
                            if tcgen then returnTm i err (recoverableCoverage ctxt err)
                                  else returnTm i err (validCoverageCase ctxt err ||
                                                 recoverableCoverage ctxt err)
  where returnTm i err True = do logLvl 10 $ "Possibly resolvable error on " ++
                                    pshow i (fmap (normalise (tt_ctxt i) []) err)
                                              ++ " on " ++ showTmImpls lhs_in
                                 return $ Just lhs_in
        returnTm i err False = return $ Nothing

-- Filter out the terms which are not well type left hand sides. Whenever we
-- eliminate one, also eliminate later ones which match it without checking,
-- because they're obviously going to have the same result
checkPossibles :: ElabInfo -> FC -> Bool -> Name -> [PTerm] -> Idris [PTerm]
checkPossibles info fc tcgen fname (lhs : rest)
   = do ok <- checkPossible info fc tcgen fname lhs
        i <- getIState
        -- Hypothesis: any we can remove will be within the next few, because
        -- leftmost patterns tend to change less
        -- Since the match could take a while if there's a lot of cases to
        -- check, just remove from the next batch
        let rest' = filter (\x -> not (qmatch x lhs)) (take 200 rest) ++ drop 200 rest
        restpos <- checkPossibles info fc tcgen fname rest'
        case ok of
             Nothing -> return restpos
             Just lhstm -> return (lhstm : restpos)
  where
    qmatch _ Placeholder = True
    qmatch (PApp _ f args) (PApp _ f' args')
       | length args == length args'
            = qmatch f f' && and (zipWith qmatch (map getTm args)
                                                 (map getTm args'))
    qmatch (PRef _ _ n) (PRef _ _ n') = n == n'
    qmatch (PPair _ _ _ l r) (PPair _ _ _ l' r') = qmatch l l' && qmatch r r'
    qmatch (PDPair _ _ _ l t r) (PDPair _ _ _ l' t' r')
          = qmatch l l' && qmatch t t' && qmatch r r'
    qmatch x y = x == y
checkPossibles _ _ _ _ [] = return []

findUnique :: Context -> Env -> Term -> [Name]
findUnique ctxt env (Bind n b sc)
   = let rawTy = forgetEnv (map fstEnv env) (binderTy b)
         uniq = case check ctxt env rawTy of
                     OK (_, UType UniqueType) -> True
                     OK (_, UType NullType) -> True
                     OK (_, UType AllTypes) -> True
                     _ -> False in
         if uniq then n : findUnique ctxt ((n, RigW, b) : env) sc
                 else findUnique ctxt ((n, RigW, b) : env) sc
findUnique _ _ _ = []

-- | Return the elaborated LHS/RHS, and the original LHS with implicits added
elabClause :: ElabInfo -> FnOpts -> (Int, PClause) ->
              Idris (Either Term (Term, Term), PTerm)
elabClause info opts (_, PClause fc fname lhs_in [] PImpossible [])
   = do let tcgen = Dictionary `elem` opts
        i <- get
        let lhs = addImpl [] i lhs_in
        b <- checkPossible info fc tcgen fname lhs_in
        case b of
            Just _ -> tclift $ tfail (At fc
                                 (Msg $ show lhs_in ++ " is a valid case"))
            Nothing -> do ptm <- mkPatTm lhs_in
                          logElab 5 $ "Elaborated impossible case " ++ showTmImpls lhs ++
                                      "\n" ++ show ptm
                          return (Left ptm, lhs)
elabClause info opts (cnum, PClause fc fname lhs_in_as withs rhs_in_as whereblock)
   = do let tcgen = Dictionary `elem` opts
        push_estack fname False
        ctxt <- getContext
        let (lhs_in, rhs_in) = desugarAs lhs_in_as rhs_in_as

        -- Build the LHS as an "Infer", and pull out its type and
        -- pattern bindings
        i <- getIState
        inf <- isTyInferred fname

        -- Check if we have "with" patterns outside of "with" block
        when (isOutsideWith lhs_in && (not $ null withs)) $
            ierror (At fc (Elaborating "left hand side of " fname Nothing
                          (Msg "unexpected patterns outside of \"with\" block")))

        -- get the parameters first, to pass through to any where block
        let fn_ty = case lookupTy fname ctxt of
                         [t] -> t
                         _ -> error "Can't happen (elabClause function type)"
        let fn_is = case lookupCtxt fname (idris_implicits i) of
                         [t] -> t
                         _ -> []
        let norm_ty = normalise ctxt [] fn_ty
        let params = getParamsInType i [] fn_is norm_ty
        let tcparams = getTCParamsInType i [] fn_is norm_ty

        let lhs = mkLHSapp $ stripLinear i $ stripUnmatchable i $
                    propagateParams i params norm_ty (allNamesIn lhs_in) (addImplPat i lhs_in)

--         let lhs = mkLHSapp $
--                     propagateParams i params fn_ty (addImplPat i lhs_in)
        logElab 10 (show (params, fn_ty) ++ " " ++ showTmImpls (addImplPat i lhs_in))
        logElab 5 ("LHS: " ++ show opts ++ "\n" ++ show fc ++ " " ++ showTmImpls lhs)
        logElab 4 ("Fixed parameters: " ++ show params ++ " from " ++ showTmImpls lhs_in ++
                  "\n" ++ show (fn_ty, fn_is))

        ((ElabResult lhs' dlhs [] ctxt' newDecls highlights newGName, probs, inj), _) <-
           tclift $ elaborate (constraintNS info) ctxt (idris_datatypes i) (idris_name i) (sMN 0 "patLHS") infP initEState
                    (do res <- errAt "left hand side of " fname Nothing
                                 (erun fc (buildTC i info ELHS opts fname
                                          (allNamesIn lhs_in)
                                          (infTerm lhs)))
                        probs <- get_probs
                        inj <- get_inj
                        return (res, probs, inj))
        setContext ctxt'
        processTacticDecls info newDecls
        sendHighlighting highlights
        updateIState $ \i -> i { idris_name = newGName }

        when inf $ addTyInfConstraints fc (map (\(x,y,_,_,_,_,_) -> (x,y)) probs)

        let lhs_tm = orderPats (getInferTerm lhs')
        let lhs_ty = getInferType lhs'
        let static_names = getStaticNames i lhs_tm

        logElab 3 ("Elaborated: " ++ show lhs_tm)
        logElab 3 ("Elaborated type: " ++ show lhs_ty)
        logElab 5 ("Injective: " ++ show fname ++ " " ++ show inj)

        -- If we're inferring metavariables in the type, don't recheck,
        -- because we're only doing this to try to work out those metavariables
        ctxt <- getContext
        (clhs_c, clhsty) <- if not inf
                               then recheckC_borrowing False (PEGenerated `notElem` opts)
                                                       [] (constraintNS info) fc id [] lhs_tm
                               else return (lhs_tm, lhs_ty)
        let clhs = normalise ctxt [] clhs_c
        let borrowed = borrowedNames [] clhs

        -- These are the names we're not allowed to use on the RHS, because
        -- they're UniqueTypes and borrowed from another function.
        when (not (null borrowed)) $
          logElab 5 ("Borrowed names on LHS: " ++ show borrowed)

        logElab 3 ("Normalised LHS: " ++ showTmImpls (delabMV i clhs))

        rep <- useREPL
        when rep $ do
          addInternalApp (fc_fname fc) (fst . fc_start $ fc) (delabMV i clhs) -- TODO: Should use span instead of line and filename?
        addIBC (IBCLineApp (fc_fname fc) (fst . fc_start $ fc) (delabMV i clhs))

        logElab 5 ("Checked " ++ show clhs ++ "\n" ++ show clhsty)
        -- Elaborate where block
        ist <- getIState
        ctxt <- getContext

        windex <- getName
        let decls = nub (concatMap declared whereblock)
        let defs = nub (decls ++ concatMap defined whereblock)
        let newargs_all = pvars ist lhs_tm

        -- Unique arguments must be passed to the where block explicitly
        -- (since we can't control "usage" easlily otherwise). Remove them
        -- from newargs here
        let uniqargs = findUnique ctxt [] lhs_tm
        let newargs = filter (\(n,_) -> n `notElem` uniqargs) newargs_all

        let winfo = (pinfo info newargs defs windex) { elabFC = Just fc }
        let wb = map (mkStatic static_names) $
                 map (expandImplementationScope ist decorate newargs defs) $
                 map (expandParamsD False ist decorate newargs defs) whereblock

        -- Split the where block into declarations with a type, and those
        -- without
        -- Elaborate those with a type *before* RHS, those without *after*
        let (wbefore, wafter) = sepBlocks wb

        logElab 5 $ "Where block:\n " ++ show wbefore ++ "\n" ++ show wafter
        mapM_ (rec_elabDecl info EAll winfo) wbefore
        -- Now build the RHS, using the type of the LHS as the goal.
        i <- getIState -- new implicits from where block
        logElab 5 (showTmImpls (expandParams decorate newargs defs (defs \\ decls) rhs_in))
        let rhs = rhs_trans info $
                   addImplBoundInf i (map fst newargs_all) (defs \\ decls)
                                 (expandParams decorate newargs defs (defs \\ decls) rhs_in)
        logElab 2 $ "RHS: " ++ show (map fst newargs_all) ++ " " ++ showTmImpls rhs
        ctxt <- getContext -- new context with where block added
        logElab 5 "STARTING CHECK"
        ((rhsElab, defer, holes, is, probs, ctxt', newDecls, highlights, newGName), _) <-
           tclift $ elaborate (constraintNS info) ctxt (idris_datatypes i) (idris_name i) (sMN 0 "patRHS") clhsty initEState
                    (do pbinds ist lhs_tm
                        -- proof search can use explicitly written names
                        mapM_ addPSname (allNamesIn lhs_in)
                        ulog <- getUnifyLog
                        traceWhen ulog ("Setting injective: " ++ show (nub (tcparams ++ inj))) $
                          mapM_ setinj (nub (tcparams ++ inj))
                        setNextName
                        (ElabResult _ _ is ctxt' newDecls highlights newGName) <-
                          errAt "right hand side of " fname (Just clhsty)
                                (erun fc (build i winfo ERHS opts fname rhs))
                        errAt "right hand side of " fname (Just clhsty)
                              (erun fc $ psolve lhs_tm)
                        tt <- get_term
                        aux <- getAux
                        let (tm, ds) = runState (collectDeferred (Just fname)
                                                     (map fst $ case_decls aux) ctxt tt) []
                        probs <- get_probs
                        hs <- get_holes
                        return (tm, ds, hs, is, probs, ctxt', newDecls, highlights, newGName))
        setContext ctxt'
        processTacticDecls info newDecls
        sendHighlighting highlights
        updateIState $ \i -> i { idris_name = newGName }

        when inf $ addTyInfConstraints fc (map (\(x,y,_,_,_,_,_) -> (x,y)) probs)

        logElab 3 "DONE CHECK"
        logElab 3 $ "---> " ++ show rhsElab
        ctxt <- getContext

        let rhs' = rhsElab

        when (not (null defer)) $ logElab 1 $ "DEFERRED " ++
                    show (map (\ (n, (_,_,t,_)) -> (n, t)) defer)

        -- If there's holes, set the metavariables as undefinable
        def' <- checkDef info fc (\n -> Elaborating "deferred type of " n Nothing) (null holes) defer
        let def'' = map (\(n, (i, top, t, ns)) -> (n, (i, top, t, ns, False, null holes))) def'
        addDeferred def''

        mapM_ (\(n, _) -> addIBC (IBCDef n)) def''

        when (not (null def')) $ do
           mapM_ defer_totcheck (map (\x -> (fc, fst x)) def'')

        -- Now the remaining deferred (i.e. no type declarations) clauses
        -- from the where block

        mapM_ (rec_elabDecl info EAll winfo) wafter
        mapM_ (elabCaseBlock winfo opts) is

        ctxt <- getContext
        logElab 5 "Rechecking"
        logElab 6 $ " ==> " ++ show (forget rhs')

        (crhs, crhsty) -- if there's holes && deferred things, it's okay
                       -- but we'll need to freeze the definition and not
                       -- allow the deferred things to be definable
                       -- (this is just to allow users to inspect intermediate
                       -- things)
             <- if (null holes || null def') && not inf
                   then recheckC_borrowing True (PEGenerated `notElem` opts)
                                       borrowed (constraintNS info) fc id [] rhs'
                   else return (rhs', clhsty)

        logElab 6 $ " ==> " ++ showEnvDbg [] crhsty ++ "   against   " ++ showEnvDbg [] clhsty

        -- If there's holes, make sure this definition is frozen
        when (not (null holes)) $ do
           logElab 5 $ "Making " ++ show fname ++ " frozen due to " ++ show holes
           setAccessibility fname Frozen

        ctxt <- getContext
        let constv = next_tvar ctxt
        tit <- typeInType
        case LState.runStateT (convertsC ctxt [] crhsty clhsty) (constv, []) of
            OK (_, cs) -> when (PEGenerated `notElem` opts && not tit) $ do
                             addConstraints fc cs
                             mapM_ (\c -> addIBC (IBCConstraint fc c)) (snd cs)
                             logElab 6 $ "CONSTRAINTS ADDED: " ++ show cs ++ "\n" ++ show (clhsty, crhsty)
                             return ()
            Error e -> ierror (At fc (CantUnify False (clhsty, Nothing) (crhsty, Nothing) e [] 0))
        i <- getIState
        checkInferred fc (delab' i crhs True True) rhs
        -- if the function is declared '%error_reverse',
        -- then we'll try running it in reverse to improve error messages
        -- Also if the type is '%error_reverse' and the LHS is smaller than
        -- the RHS
        let (ret_fam, _) = unApply (getRetTy crhsty)
        rev <- case ret_fam of
                    P _ rfamn _ ->
                        case lookupCtxt rfamn (idris_datatypes i) of
                             [TI _ _ dopts _ _ _] ->
                                 return (DataErrRev `elem` dopts &&
                                         size clhs <= size crhs)
                             _ -> return False
                    _ -> return False

        when (rev || ErrorReverse `elem` opts) $ do
           addIBC (IBCErrRev (crhs, clhs))
           addErrRev (crhs, clhs)
        when (rev || ErrorReduce `elem` opts) $ do
           addIBC (IBCErrReduce fname)
           addErrReduce fname
        pop_estack
        return (Right (clhs, crhs), lhs)
  where
    pinfo :: ElabInfo -> [(Name, PTerm)] -> [Name] -> Int -> ElabInfo
    pinfo info ns ds i
          = let newps = params info ++ ns
                dsParams = map (\n -> (n, map fst newps)) ds
                newb = addAlist dsParams (inblock info)
                l = liftname info in
                info { params = newps,
                       inblock = newb,
                       liftname = id -- (\n -> case lookupCtxt n newb of
                                     --      Nothing -> n
                                     --      _ -> MN i (show n)) . l
                     }

    -- Find the variable names which appear under a 'Ownership.Read' so that
    -- we know they can't be used on the RHS
    borrowedNames :: [Name] -> Term -> [Name]
    borrowedNames env (App _ (App _ (P _ (NS (UN lend) [owner]) _) _) arg)
        | owner == txt "Ownership" &&
          (lend == txt "lend" || lend == txt "Read") = getVs arg
       where
         getVs (V i) = [env!!i]
         getVs (App _ f a) = nub $ getVs f ++ getVs a
         getVs _ = []
    borrowedNames env (App _ f a) = nub $ borrowedNames env f ++ borrowedNames env a
    borrowedNames env (Bind n b sc) = nub $ borrowedB b ++ borrowedNames (n:env) sc
       where borrowedB (Let t v) = nub $ borrowedNames env t ++ borrowedNames env v
             borrowedB b = borrowedNames env (binderTy b)
    borrowedNames _ _ = []

    mkLHSapp t@(PRef _ _ _) = PApp fc t []
    mkLHSapp t = t

    decorate (NS x ns)
       = NS (SN (WhereN cnum fname x)) ns
    decorate x
       = SN (WhereN cnum fname x)

    sepBlocks bs = sepBlocks' [] bs where
      sepBlocks' ns (d@(PTy _ _ _ _ _ n _ t) : bs)
            = let (bf, af) = sepBlocks' (n : ns) bs in
                  (d : bf, af)
      sepBlocks' ns (d@(PClauses _ _ n _) : bs)
         | not (n `elem` ns) = let (bf, af) = sepBlocks' ns bs in
                                   (bf, d : af)
      sepBlocks' ns (b : bs) = let (bf, af) = sepBlocks' ns bs in
                                   (b : bf, af)
      sepBlocks' ns [] = ([], [])

    -- term is not within "with" block
    isOutsideWith :: PTerm -> Bool
    isOutsideWith (PApp _ (PRef _ _ (SN (WithN _ _))) _) = False
    isOutsideWith _ = True

elabClause info opts (_, PWith fc fname lhs_in withs wval_in pn_in withblock)
   = do let tcgen = Dictionary `elem` opts
        ctxt <- getContext
        -- Build the LHS as an "Infer", and pull out its type and
        -- pattern bindings
        i <- getIState
        -- get the parameters first, to pass through to any where block
        let fn_ty = case lookupTy fname ctxt of
                         [t] -> t
                         _ -> error "Can't happen (elabClause function type)"
        let fn_is = case lookupCtxt fname (idris_implicits i) of
                         [t] -> t
                         _ -> []
        let params = getParamsInType i [] fn_is (normalise ctxt [] fn_ty)
        let lhs = stripLinear i $ stripUnmatchable i $
                   propagateParams i params fn_ty (allNamesIn lhs_in)
                    (addImplPat i lhs_in)
        logElab 2 ("LHS: " ++ show lhs)
        (ElabResult lhs' dlhs [] ctxt' newDecls highlights newGName, _) <-
            tclift $ elaborate (constraintNS info) ctxt (idris_datatypes i) (idris_name i) (sMN 0 "patLHS") infP initEState
              (errAt "left hand side of with in " fname Nothing
                (erun fc (buildTC i info ELHS opts fname
                                  (allNamesIn lhs_in)
                                  (infTerm lhs))) )
        setContext ctxt'
        processTacticDecls info newDecls
        sendHighlighting highlights
        updateIState $ \i -> i { idris_name = newGName }

        ctxt <- getContext
        let lhs_tm = orderPats (getInferTerm lhs')
        let lhs_ty = getInferType lhs'
        let ret_ty = getRetTy (explicitNames (normalise ctxt [] lhs_ty))
        let static_names = getStaticNames i lhs_tm
        logElab 5 (show lhs_tm ++ "\n" ++ show static_names)
        (clhs_c, clhsty) <- recheckC (constraintNS info) fc id [] lhs_tm
        let clhs = normalise ctxt [] clhs_c

        logElab 5 ("Checked " ++ show clhs)
        let bargs = getPBtys (explicitNames (normalise ctxt [] lhs_tm))
        wval <- case wval_in of
                     Placeholder -> ierror $ At fc $
                          Msg "No expression for the with block to inspect.\nYou need to replace the _ with an expression."
                     _ -> return $
                            rhs_trans info $
                              addImplBound i (map fst bargs) wval_in
        logElab 5 ("Checking " ++ showTmImpls wval)
        -- Elaborate wval in this context
        ((wvalElab, defer, is, ctxt', newDecls, highlights, newGName), _) <-
            tclift $ elaborate (constraintNS info) ctxt (idris_datatypes i) (idris_name i) (sMN 0 "withRHS")
                        (bindTyArgs PVTy bargs infP) initEState
                        (do pbinds i lhs_tm
                            -- proof search can use explicitly written names
                            mapM_ addPSname (allNamesIn lhs_in)
                            setNextName
                            -- TODO: may want where here - see winfo abpve
                            (ElabResult _ d is ctxt' newDecls highlights newGName) <- errAt "with value in " fname Nothing
                              (erun fc (build i info ERHS opts fname (infTerm wval)))
                            erun fc $ psolve lhs_tm
                            tt <- get_term
                            return (tt, d, is, ctxt', newDecls, highlights, newGName))
        setContext ctxt'
        processTacticDecls info newDecls
        sendHighlighting highlights
        updateIState $ \i -> i { idris_name = newGName }

        def' <- checkDef info fc iderr True defer
        let def'' = map (\(n, (i, top, t, ns)) -> (n, (i, top, t, ns, False, True))) def'
        addDeferred def''
        mapM_ (elabCaseBlock info opts) is

        let wval' = wvalElab
        logElab 5 ("Checked wval " ++ show wval')

        ctxt <- getContext
        (cwval, cwvalty) <- recheckC (constraintNS info) fc id [] (getInferTerm wval')
        let cwvaltyN = explicitNames (normalise ctxt [] cwvalty)
        let cwvalN = explicitNames (normalise ctxt [] cwval)
        logElab 3 ("With type " ++ show cwvalty ++ "\nRet type " ++ show ret_ty)
        -- We're going to assume the with type is not a function shortly,
        -- so report an error if it is (you can't match on a function anyway
        -- so this doesn't lose anything)
        case getArgTys cwvaltyN of
             [] -> return ()
             (_:_) -> ierror $ At fc (WithFnType cwvalty)

        let pvars = map fst (getPBtys cwvalty)
        -- we need the unelaborated term to get the names it depends on
        -- rather than a de Bruijn index.
        let pdeps = usedNamesIn pvars i (delab i cwvalty)
        let (bargs_pre, bargs_post) = split pdeps bargs []

        let mpn = case pn_in of
                       Nothing -> Nothing
                       Just (n, nfc) -> Just (uniqueName n (map fst bargs))

        -- Highlight explicit proofs
        sendHighlighting [(fc, AnnBoundName n False) | (n, fc) <- maybeToList pn_in]

        logElab 10 ("With type " ++ show (getRetTy cwvaltyN) ++
                  " depends on " ++ show pdeps ++ " from " ++ show pvars)
        logElab 10 ("Pre " ++ show bargs_pre ++ "\nPost " ++ show bargs_post)
        windex <- getName
        -- build a type declaration for the new function:
        -- (ps : Xs) -> (withval : cwvalty) -> (ps' : Xs') -> ret_ty
        let wargval = getRetTy cwvalN
        let wargtype = getRetTy cwvaltyN
        let wargname = sMN windex "warg"

        logElab 5 ("Abstract over " ++ show wargval ++ " in " ++ show wargtype)
        let wtype = bindTyArgs (flip (Pi RigW Nothing) (TType (UVar [] 0))) (bargs_pre ++
                     (wargname, wargtype) :
                     map (abstract wargname wargval wargtype) bargs_post ++
                     case mpn of
                          Just pn -> [(pn, mkApp (P Ref eqTy Erased)
                                       [wargtype, wargtype,
                                         P Bound wargname Erased, wargval])]
                          Nothing -> [])
                     (substTerm wargval (P Bound wargname wargtype) ret_ty)
        logElab 3 ("New function type " ++ show wtype)
        let wname = SN (WithN windex fname)

        let imps = getImps wtype -- add to implicits context
        putIState (i { idris_implicits = addDef wname imps (idris_implicits i) })
        let statics = getStatics static_names wtype
        logElab 5 ("Static positions " ++ show statics)
        i <- getIState
        putIState (i { idris_statics = addDef wname statics (idris_statics i) })

        addIBC (IBCDef wname)
        addIBC (IBCImp wname)
        addIBC (IBCStatic wname)

        def' <- checkDef info fc iderr True [(wname, (-1, Nothing, wtype, []))]
        let def'' = map (\(n, (i, top, t, ns)) -> (n, (i, top, t, ns, False, True))) def'
        addDeferred def''

        -- in the subdecls, lhs becomes:
        --         fname  pats | wpat [rest]
        --    ==>  fname' ps   wpat [rest], match pats against toplevel for ps
        wb <- mapM (mkAuxC mpn wname lhs (map fst bargs_pre) (map fst bargs_post))
                       withblock
        logElab 3 ("with block " ++ show wb)
        setFlags wname [Inlinable]
        when (AssertTotal `elem` opts) $
           setFlags wname [Inlinable, AssertTotal]
        i <- getIState
        let rhstrans' = updateWithTerm i mpn wname lhs (map fst bargs_pre) (map fst (bargs_post))
                             . rhs_trans info
        mapM_ (rec_elabDecl info EAll (info { rhs_trans = rhstrans' })) wb

        -- rhs becomes: fname' ps_pre wval ps_post Refl
        let rhs = PApp fc (PRef fc [] wname)
                    (map (pexp . (PRef fc []) . fst) bargs_pre ++
                        pexp wval :
                    (map (pexp . (PRef fc []) . fst) bargs_post) ++
                    case mpn of
                         Nothing -> []
                         Just _ -> [pexp (PApp NoFC (PRef NoFC [] eqCon)
                                               [ pimp (sUN "A") Placeholder False
                                               , pimp (sUN "x") Placeholder False
                                               ])])
        logElab 5 ("New RHS " ++ showTmImpls rhs)
        ctxt <- getContext -- New context with block added
        i <- getIState
        ((rhsElab, defer, is, ctxt', newDecls, highlights, newGName), _) <-
           tclift $ elaborate (constraintNS info) ctxt (idris_datatypes i) (idris_name i) (sMN 0 "wpatRHS") clhsty initEState
                    (do pbinds i lhs_tm
                        setNextName
                        (ElabResult _ d is ctxt' newDecls highlights newGName) <-
                           erun fc (build i info ERHS opts fname rhs)
                        psolve lhs_tm
                        tt <- get_term
                        return (tt, d, is, ctxt', newDecls, highlights, newGName))
        setContext ctxt'

        processTacticDecls info newDecls
        sendHighlighting highlights
        updateIState $ \i -> i { idris_name = newGName }

        ctxt <- getContext
        let rhs' = rhsElab

        def' <- checkDef info fc iderr True defer
        let def'' = map (\(n, (i, top, t, ns)) -> (n, (i, top, t, ns, False, True))) def'
        addDeferred def''
        mapM_ (elabCaseBlock info opts) is
        logElab 5 ("Checked RHS " ++ show rhs')
        (crhs, crhsty) <- recheckC (constraintNS info) fc id [] rhs'
        return (Right (clhs, crhs), lhs)
  where
    getImps (Bind n (Pi _ _ _ _) t) = pexp Placeholder : getImps t
    getImps _ = []

    mkAuxC pn wname lhs ns ns' (PClauses fc o n cs)
                = do cs' <- mapM (mkAux pn wname lhs ns ns') cs
                     return $ PClauses fc o wname cs'
    mkAuxC pn wname lhs ns ns' d = return d

    mkAux pn wname toplhs ns ns' (PClause fc n tm_in (w:ws) rhs wheres)
        = do i <- getIState
             let tm = addImplPat i tm_in
             logElab 2 ("Matching " ++ showTmImpls tm ++ " against " ++
                                      showTmImpls toplhs)
             case matchClause i toplhs tm of
                Left (a,b) -> ifail $ show fc ++ ":with clause does not match top level"
                Right mvars ->
                    do logElab 3 ("Match vars : " ++ show mvars)
                       lhs <- updateLHS n pn wname mvars ns ns' (fullApp tm) w
                       return $ PClause fc wname lhs ws rhs wheres
    mkAux pn wname toplhs ns ns' (PWith fc n tm_in (w:ws) wval pn' withs)
        = do i <- getIState
             let tm = addImplPat i tm_in
             logElab 2 ("Matching " ++ showTmImpls tm ++ " against " ++
                                      showTmImpls toplhs)
             withs' <- mapM (mkAuxC pn wname toplhs ns ns') withs
             case matchClause i toplhs tm of
                Left (a,b) -> trace ("matchClause: " ++ show a ++ " =/= " ++ show b) (ifail $ show fc ++ "with clause does not match top level")
                Right mvars ->
                    do lhs <- updateLHS n pn wname mvars ns ns' (fullApp tm) w
                       return $ PWith fc wname lhs ws wval pn' withs'
    mkAux pn wname toplhs ns ns' c
        = ifail $ show fc ++ ":badly formed with clause"

    addArg (PApp fc f args) w = PApp fc f (args ++ [pexp w])
    addArg (PRef fc hls f) w = PApp fc (PRef fc hls f) [pexp w]

    -- ns, arguments which don't depend on the with argument
    -- ns', arguments which do
    updateLHS n pn wname mvars ns_in ns_in' (PApp fc (PRef fc' hls' n') args) w
        = let ns = map (keepMvar (map fst mvars) fc') ns_in
              ns' = map (keepMvar (map fst mvars) fc') ns_in' in
              return $ substMatches mvars $
                  PApp fc (PRef fc' [] wname)
                      (map pexp ns ++ pexp w : (map pexp ns') ++
                        case pn of
                             Nothing -> []
                             Just pnm -> [pexp (PRef fc [] pnm)])
    updateLHS n pn wname mvars ns_in ns_in' tm w
        = updateLHS n pn wname mvars ns_in ns_in' (PApp fc tm []) w

    -- Only keep a var as a pattern variable in the with block if it's
    -- matched in the top level pattern
    keepMvar mvs fc v | v `elem` mvs = PRef fc [] v
                      | otherwise = Placeholder

    updateWithTerm :: IState -> Maybe Name -> Name -> PTerm -> [Name] -> [Name] -> PTerm -> PTerm
    updateWithTerm ist pn wname toplhs ns_in ns_in' tm
          = mapPT updateApp tm
       where
         arity (PApp _ _ as) = length as
         arity _ = 0

         lhs_arity = arity toplhs

         currentFn fname (PAlternative _ _ as)
              | Just tm <- getApp as = tm
            where getApp (tm@(PApp _ (PRef _ _ f) _) : as)
                      | f == fname = Just tm
                  getApp (_ : as) = getApp as
                  getApp [] = Nothing
         currentFn _ tm = tm

         updateApp wtm@(PWithApp fcw tm_in warg) =
           let tm = currentFn fname tm_in in
              case matchClause ist toplhs tm of
                Left _ -> PElabError (Msg (show fc ++ ":with application does not match top level "))
                Right mvars ->
                   let ns = map (keepMvar (map fst mvars) fcw) ns_in
                       ns' = map (keepMvar (map fst mvars) fcw) ns_in'
                       wty = lookupTyExact wname (tt_ctxt ist)
                       res = substMatches mvars $
                          PApp fcw (PRef fcw [] wname)
                            (map pexp ns ++ pexp warg : (map pexp ns') ++
                                case pn of
                                     Nothing -> []
                                     Just pnm -> [pexp (PRef fc [] pnm)]) in
                          case wty of
                               Nothing -> res -- can't happen!
                               Just ty -> addResolves ty res
         updateApp tm = tm

         addResolves ty (PApp fc f args) = PApp fc f (addResolvesArgs fc ty args)
         addResolves ty tm = tm

         -- if an argument's type is an interface, and is otherwise to
         -- be inferred, then resolve it with implementation search
         -- This is something of a hack, because matching on the top level
         -- application won't find this information for us
         addResolvesArgs :: FC -> Term -> [PArg] -> [PArg]
         addResolvesArgs fc (Bind n (Pi _ _ ty _) sc) (a : args)
             | (P _ cn _, _) <- unApply ty,
               getTm a == Placeholder
                 = case lookupCtxtExact cn (idris_interfaces ist) of
                        Just _ -> a { getTm = PResolveTC fc } : addResolvesArgs fc sc args
                        Nothing -> a : addResolvesArgs fc sc args
         addResolvesArgs fc (Bind n (Pi _ _ ty _) sc) (a : args)
                 = a : addResolvesArgs fc sc args
         addResolvesArgs fc _ args = args

    fullApp (PApp _ (PApp fc f args) xs) = fullApp (PApp fc f (args ++ xs))
    fullApp x = x

    split [] rest pre = (reverse pre, rest)
    split deps ((n, ty) : rest) pre
          | n `elem` deps = split (deps \\ [n]) rest ((n, ty) : pre)
          | otherwise = split deps rest ((n, ty) : pre)
    split deps [] pre = (reverse pre, [])

    abstract wn wv wty (n, argty) = (n, substTerm wv (P Bound wn wty) argty)

-- | Apply a transformation to all RHSes and nested RHSs
mapRHS :: (PTerm -> PTerm) -> PClause -> PClause
mapRHS f (PClause fc n lhs args rhs ws)
    = PClause fc n lhs args (f rhs) (map (mapRHSdecl f) ws)
mapRHS f (PWith fc n lhs args warg prf ws)
    = PWith fc n lhs args (f warg) prf (map (mapRHSdecl f) ws)
mapRHS f (PClauseR fc args rhs ws)
    = PClauseR fc args (f rhs) (map (mapRHSdecl f) ws)
mapRHS f (PWithR fc args warg prf ws)
    = PWithR fc args (f warg) prf (map (mapRHSdecl f) ws)

mapRHSdecl :: (PTerm -> PTerm) -> PDecl -> PDecl
mapRHSdecl f (PClauses fc opt n cs)
    = PClauses fc opt n (map (mapRHS f) cs)
mapRHSdecl f t = t