{-# LANGUAGE PatternGuards #-} -- | Simply-typed Curry-style (nominal) lambda-calculus -- with integers and zero-comparison -- Type inference, of the type and of the environment, aka -- conditional typechecking -- This code does not in general infer polymorphic bindings as this is akin -- to higher-order unification. -- -- The benefit of the approach: we can handle _open_ terms. -- Some of them we type check, and some of them we reject. The rejection means -- the term cannot be typed in _any_ type environment. -- -- One often hears a complaint against typing: one can evaluate -- terms we can't even type check. This code shows that we can type check -- terms we can't even evaluate. -- -- We cannot evaluate open terms at all, but we can type check them, -- inferring both the type as well as the _requirement_ -- on the environments in which the term must be used. -- -- -- module Language.TEval.TInfTEnv where import qualified Data.IntMap as M data Typ = TInt | !Typ :> !Typ | TV TVarName deriving (Show, Eq) infixr 9 :> type TVarName = Int data Term = V VarName | L VarName Term | A Term Term | I Int | Term :+ Term -- addition | IFZ Term Term Term -- if zero | Fix Term -- fix f, where f :: (a->b)->(a->b) deriving (Show, Eq) infixl 9 `A` type VarName = String -- | Type Environment: associating types with `free' term variables type TEnv = [(VarName, Typ)] env0 :: TEnv env0 = [] lkup :: TEnv -> VarName -> Typ lkup env x = maybe err id $ lookup x env where err = error $ "Unbound variable " ++ x ext :: TEnv -> (VarName,Typ) -> TEnv ext env xt = xt : env unext :: TEnv -> VarName -> TEnv unext env v = case break (\(x,_) -> x == v) env of (h,(_:t)) -> h ++ t _ -> error $ "No variable " ++ v env_map :: (Typ->Typ) -> TEnv -> TEnv env_map f = map (\(x,t) -> (x,f t)) -- | Merge two environment, using the given function to resolve the conflicts, -- if any env_fold_merge :: TEnv -> TEnv -> (Typ -> Typ -> seed -> Either err seed) -> seed -> Either err (TEnv,seed) env_fold_merge env1 env2 f seed = foldr folder (Right (env1,seed)) env2 where folder _ s@(Left _) = s folder (x,t2) (Right (env1,seed)) | Just t1 <- lookup x env1 = case f t1 t2 seed of Right seed -> Right (env1,seed) Left err -> Left err folder xt2 (Right (env1,seed)) = Right (ext env1 xt2,seed) -- | Type Variable Environment: associating types with `free' type variables data TVE = TVE Int (M.IntMap Typ) deriving Show -- | Allocate a fresh type variable (see the first component of TVE) newtv :: TVE -> (Typ,TVE) newtv (TVE n s) = (TV n,TVE (succ n) s) tve0 :: TVE tve0 = TVE 0 M.empty tvlkup :: TVE -> TVarName -> Maybe Typ tvlkup (TVE _ s) v = M.lookup v s tvext :: TVE -> (TVarName,Typ) -> TVE tvext (TVE c s) (tv,t) = TVE c $ M.insert tv t s -- | Type variables are logic variables: hypothetical reasoning tvsub :: TVE -> Typ -> Typ tvsub tve (t1 :> t2) = tvsub tve t1 :> tvsub tve t2 tvsub tve (TV v) | Just t <- tvlkup tve v = tvsub tve t tvsub tve t = t -- | `shallow' substitution; check if tv is bound to anything `substantial' tvchase :: TVE -> Typ -> Typ tvchase tve (TV v) | Just t <- tvlkup tve v = tvchase tve t tvchase _ t = t -- | The unification. If unification failed, return the reason unify :: Typ -> Typ -> TVE -> Either String TVE unify t1 t2 tve = unify' (tvchase tve t1) (tvchase tve t2) tve -- | If either t1 or t2 are type variables, they are definitely unbound unify' :: Typ -> Typ -> TVE -> Either String TVE unify' TInt TInt = Right unify' (t1a :> t1r) (t2a :> t2r) = either Left (unify t1r t2r) . unify t1a t2a unify' (TV v1) t2 = unifyv v1 t2 unify' t1 (TV v2) = unifyv v2 t1 unify' t1 t2 = const (Left $ unwords ["constant mismatch:",show t1,"and", show t2]) -- | Unify a free variable v1 with t2 unifyv :: TVarName -> Typ -> TVE -> Either String TVE unifyv v1 (TV v2) tve = if v1 == v2 then Right tve else Right (tvext tve (v1,TV v2)) -- record new constraint unifyv v1 t2 tve = if occurs v1 t2 tve then Left $ unwords ["occurs check:",show (TV v1), "in",show $ tvsub tve t2] else Right (tvext tve (v1,t2)) -- | The occurs check: if v appears free in t occurs :: TVarName -> Typ -> TVE -> Bool occurs v TInt _ = False occurs v (t1 :> t2) tve = occurs v t1 tve || occurs v t2 tve occurs v (TV v2) tve = case tvlkup tve v2 of Nothing -> v == v2 Just t -> occurs v t tve merge_env :: TEnv -> TEnv -> (TVE -> (TEnv,TVE)) merge_env env1 env2 tve = either error id $ env_fold_merge env1 env2 unify tve -- | Type reconstruction: abstract evaluation teval' :: Term -> (TVE -> (Typ,TEnv,TVE)) teval' (V x) = \tve0 -> let (tv,tve1) = newtv tve0 env1 = ext env0 (x,tv) in (tv,env1,tve1) teval' (L x e) = \tve0 -> let (tv,tve1) = newtv tve0 env1 = ext env0 (x,tv) (te,env2,tve2) = teval' e tve1 (env3,tve3) = merge_env env2 env1 tve2 env4 = unext env3 x in (tv :> te,env4,tve3) teval' (A e1 e2) = \tve0 -> let (t1,env1,tve1) = teval' e1 tve0 (t2,env2,tve2) = teval' e2 tve1 (env3,tve3) = merge_env env1 env2 tve2 (t1r,tve4) = newtv tve3 in case unify t1 (t2 :> t1r) tve4 of Right tve -> (t1r,env3,tve) Left err -> error $ err teval' (I n) = \tve0 -> (TInt,env0,tve0) teval' (e1 :+ e2) = \tve0 -> let (t1,env1,tve1) = teval' e1 tve0 (t2,env2,tve2) = teval' e2 tve1 (env3,tve3) = merge_env env1 env2 tve2 in case either Left (unify t2 TInt) . unify t1 TInt $ tve3 of Right tve -> (TInt,env3,tve) Left err -> error $ "Trying to add non-integers: " ++ err teval' (IFZ e1 e2 e3) = \tve0 -> let (t1,env1,tve1) = teval' e1 tve0 (t2,env2,tve2) = teval' e2 tve1 (t3,env3,tve3) = teval' e3 tve2 (env4,tve4) = merge_env env1 env2 tve3 (env5,tve5) = merge_env env4 env3 tve4 in case unify t1 TInt tve5 of Right tve -> case unify t2 t3 tve of Right tve -> (t2,env5,tve) Left err -> error $ unwords ["Branches of IFZ have different", "types. Unification failed:",err] Left err -> error $ "Trying to compare a non-integer to 0: " ++ err teval' (Fix e) = \tve0 -> let (t,env,tve1) = teval' e tve0 (ta,tve2) = newtv tve1 (tb,tve3) = newtv tve2 in case unify t ((ta :> tb) :> (ta :> tb)) tve3 of Right tve -> (ta :> tb,env,tve) Left err -> error $ "Inappropriate type in Fix: "++err -- | Resolve all type variables, as far as possible teval :: Term -> (Typ,TEnv) teval e = let (t,env,tve) = teval' e tve0 in (tvsub tve t, env_map (tvsub tve) env) -- Tests (vx,vy) = (V "x",V "y") test0 = teval' ((L "x" (vx :+ (I 2))) `A` (I 1)) tve0 -- (TV 2,[],TVE 3 (fromList [(0,TInt),(1,TInt),(2,TInt)])) term1 = L "x" (IFZ vx (I 1) (vx :+ (I 2))) test10 = teval' term1 tve0 -- (TV 0 :> TInt,[],TVE 3 (fromList [(0,TInt),(1,TInt),(2,TInt)])) -- need a better presentation of the final result: cf. teval' and teval test1 = teval term1 -- TInt :> TInt termid = L "x" vx testid = teval termid -- (TV 0 :> TV 0,[]) term2a = L "x" (L "y" (vx `A` vy)) test2a = teval term2a -- ((TV 1 :> TV 4) :> (TV 1 :> TV 4),[]) -- Used to be hidden problem. The main benefit of types: static approximation -- of program behavior -- The terms with unbound variables no longer fail the type check. -- We infer both the type and the environment term3 = L "x" (IFZ vx (I 1) vy) test3 = teval term3 -- (TInt :> TInt,[("y",TInt)]) -- That term is ill-typed in any environment... term4 = L "x" (IFZ vx (I 1) (vx `A` (I 1))) test4 = teval term4 -- compare the error message with that of test4a and test4b in TEvalNC.hs term6 = (L "x" (I 1)) `A` vy test61 = teval term6 -- (TInt,[("y",TV 1)]) test62 = teval $ (I 1) :+ vx -- (TInt,[("x",TInt)]) -- But some terms still fail type-checking: no environment could -- be found to make the term typeable test63 = teval $ IFZ (vx `A` (I 1)) vx (I 2) -- *** Exception: Branches of IFZ have different types. -- Unification failed: constant mismatch: TInt :> TV 1 and TInt -- Here two branches of the conditional make inconsistent assumptions -- about the environment test64 = teval $ IFZ (I 1) (vx `A` (I 1)) (vx :+ (I 2)) -- *** Exception: constant mismatch: TInt :> TV 1 and TInt tmul1 = L "x" (L "y" (IFZ vx (I 0) ((tmul1 `A` (vx :+ (I (-1))) `A` vy) :+ vy))) testm1 = teval tmul1 -- is typechecking really decidable? -- Can termY be typechecked? delta = L "y" (vy `A` vy) testd = teval delta tmul = Fix (L "self" (L "x" (L "y" (IFZ vx (I 0) (((V "self") `A` (vx :+ (I (-1))) `A` vy) :+ vy))))) testm21' = teval' tmul tve0 -- (TV 5 :> TV 6,TVE 7 (fromList -- [(0,TInt :> TV 3),(1,TInt),(2,TInt),(3,TV 2 :> TV 4), -- (4,TInt),(5,TInt),(6,TV 2 :> TV 4)])) testm21 = teval tmul -- TInt :> (TInt :> TInt) testm22 = teval (tmul `A` (I 2)) -- TInt :> TInt testm23 = teval (tmul `A` (I 2) `A` (I 3)) -- TInt testm24 = teval (tmul `A` (I (-1)) `A` (I (-1))) -- TInt -- using the metalanguage definition of termid: `top-level let' term2id = L "f" (L "y" ((I 2) :+ ((termid `A` (V "f")) `A` ((termid `A` vy) :+ (I 1))))) test2id = teval term2id -- (TInt :> TInt) :> (TInt :> TInt) -- using the metalanguage let termlet = let c2 = L "f" (L "x" (V "f" `A` (V "f" `A` vx))) inc = L "x" (vx :+ (I 1)) compose = L "f" (L "g" (L "x" (V "f" `A` (V "g" `A` vx)))) in c2 `A` (compose `A` inc `A` inc) `A` (I 10) :+ ((c2 `A` (compose `A` inc) `A` termid) `A` (I 100)) testlet = teval termlet -- (TInt,[])