id,summary,reporter,owner,description,type,status,priority,milestone,component,version,resolution,keywords,cc,os,architecture,failure,difficulty,testcase,blockedby,blocking,related
3734,overlapping orphan instances behave like incoherent without warning/error,Liskni_si,,"Consider these three modules:

{{{
module A where

class (Show a) => A a

data A' = A' deriving (Show)
instance A A'

data A'' = A'' deriving (Show)
instance A A''

print_a :: (A a) => a -> IO ()
print_a a = print a
}}}

{{{
{-# LANGUAGE FlexibleInstances, OverlappingInstances #-}
module B where

import A

data B a = B a deriving (Show)
instance (A a) => A (B a)
}}}

{{{
{-# LANGUAGE FlexibleInstances, OverlappingInstances #-}
module Main where

import A
import B

instance Show (B A') where
    show _ = ""kokodak""

instance Show (B A'') where
    show _ = ""brekeke""

instance A (B A'')

main :: IO ()
main = do
    print   (B A')
    print_a (B A')
    putStrLn """"
    print   (B A'')
    print_a (B A'')
}}}

Without understanding a thing about dictionaries, I would expect that if this actually compiles (which I now understand it should not), I'd get `""kokodak kokodak brekeke brekeke""` as output, but I got `""kokodak B A' brekeke brekeke""` instead.

I figured that even though I redefined `Show (B A')`, the `A (B a)` instance was defined in module `B` and consisted of the original `Show` dictionary. If I move the `Show (B A')` instance to module B, ghc complains that the definition of `A (B a)` depends on the instatiation of `a` and refuses to compile it, unless I enable `IncoherentInstances`.

The problem here is that if the `Show (B A')` instance is orphan, I get the `IncoherentInstances` behaviour for free without any warning or error, giving me the false feeling that the code is actually OK. Is it possible that ghc gives an error in this case, and may the documentation mention that Overlapping + Orphan => Incoherent?",bug,closed,normal,,Compiler (Type checker),6.10.4,fixed,,,Unknown/Multiple,Unknown/Multiple,Incorrect result at runtime,,,,,