-- Cheryls Birthday in SMCDEL VARS 5,6,7,8, -- month 14,15,16,17,18,19 -- day of the month LAW AND ( -- birthday is one of these ten possibilities: OR ( (15 & 5), (16 & 5) , (19 & 5) , (17 & 6), (18 & 6) , (14 & 7), (16 & 7) , (14 & 8), (15 & 8), (17 & 8) ), -- month must be unique: AND ( ~(5 & 6), ~(5 & 7), ~(5 & 8) , ~(6 & 7), ~(6 & 8) , ~(7 & 8) ), -- days must be unique: AND ( ~(14 & 15), ~(14 & 16), ~(14 & 17), ~(14 & 18), ~(14 & 19) , ~(15 & 16), ~(15 & 17), ~(15 & 18), ~(15 & 19) , ~(16 & 17), ~(16 & 18), ~(16 & 19) , ~(17 & 18), ~(17 & 19) , ~(18 & 19) ) ) OBS albert: 5,6,7,8 -- knows month bernard: 14,15,16,17,18,19 -- knows day -- list all states WHERE? Top -- the dialogue WHERE? -- Albert: I don't know when Cheryl's birthday is, ... < ! ~ OR ( albert knows that (15 & 5), albert knows that (16 & 5) , albert knows that (19 & 5), albert knows that (17 & 6) , albert knows that (18 & 6), albert knows that (14 & 7) , albert knows that (16 & 7), albert knows that (14 & 8) , albert knows that (15 & 8), albert knows that (17 & 8) ) > -- ... but I know that Bernard doesn't know too. < ! ( albert knows that ( ~( OR ( bernard knows that (15 & 5), bernard knows that (16 & 5) , bernard knows that (19 & 5), bernard knows that (17 & 6) , bernard knows that (18 & 6), bernard knows that (14 & 7) , bernard knows that (16 & 7), bernard knows that (14 & 8) , bernard knows that (15 & 8), bernard knows that (17 & 8) ) ) ) ) > -- Bernard: First I did not know when Cheryl's birthday is, but now I know. < ! OR ( bernard knows that (15 & 5), bernard knows that (16 & 5) , bernard knows that (19 & 5), bernard knows that (17 & 6) , bernard knows that (18 & 6), bernard knows that (14 & 7) , bernard knows that (16 & 7), bernard knows that (14 & 8) , bernard knows that (15 & 8), bernard knows that (17 & 8) ) > -- Albert: Then I also know when Cheryl's birthday is. < ! OR ( albert knows that (15 & 5), albert knows that (16 & 5) , albert knows that (19 & 5), albert knows that (17 & 6) , albert knows that (18 & 6), albert knows that (14 & 7) , albert knows that (16 & 7), albert knows that (14 & 8) , albert knows that (15 & 8), albert knows that (17 & 8) ) > -- (show all states where these announcements can be made in this order) Top